How to Believe in Myself as an Athlete: 9 Steps to Build Stronger Confidence

Every athlete, from beginners to Olympians, has been told the same thing at some point: “Just believe in yourself”. It sounds simple enough – until you’re the one standing at the court, waiting for the starting whistle. In those high-pressure moments, belief isn’t always something you can just switch on. You could think: “I want to believe in myself, but I can’t.”, or “How to believe in myself as an athlete?”. And in that moment, the advice “just believe in yourself” feels not just unhelpful, but almost impossible.

The truth is, belief in sports isn’t about empty motivation. It’s the steady fuel that allows you to trust your preparation, execute under pressure, and recover from mistakes. When self-belief is missing, it doesn’t matter how talented or well-trained you are – because your body tightens, your focus slips, and doubt takes over at the worst possible time.

If you’ve ever walked away from a competition thinking you were capable of more, but something inside held you back, you already know how critical this is. Learning about “how to believe in myself as an athlete” is about unlocking that inner trust so your performance matches your potential.

In this blog post, we will dig into why self-belief can feel so hard to access in sports, especially under stress. We will explore what psychology and neuroscience reveal about confidence, and most importantly, walk through nine practical steps that you can train – just like physical skills – to build stronger, more reliable self-belief. Because confidence is not something you either have or don’t have. It’s something you can practice, strengthen, and take with you into every competition.

Key Takeaways

• Belief is not a switch, it’s a skill – Self-belief is not built overnight or only with one pep talk. It’s developed like any athletic skill: through practice, consistency, and small daily repetitions that grow into lasting confidence.

• Your body holds the key – Confidence doesn’t just live in the mind. A calm, regulated nervous system creates the foundation where belief can stick. Learning to calm down your body under pressure is just as important as training your technique.

• Action can lead belief – You don’t have to wait to “feel ready”. Acting as if you already trust yourself – taking the penalty shot, holding your posture, speaking with confidence – teaches your brain that you are capable, even before your mind catches up.

• Rewrite the story of failure – Past mistakes and tough moments don’t define you. When you revisit them with compassion and reframe them as stepping stones, they stop being evidence against you and start becoming fuel for growth.

• Wins and losses fade, but the way you live your values leaves a lasting mark – on you, on your team, and on the people watching. Compete for who you are, not just for what you achieve.

Why Believing in Yourself Feels Hard in Sports

Athletes often assume self-belief is natural – you either have it or you don’t. But that is not true. Confidence in sports is not a single decision, it’s a pattern built over time.

If your nervous system has been wired to expect failure, rejection, or danger, then “believing” doesn’t feel motivating – it feels unsafe or fake. For many athletes, old experiences of harsh coaching, tough losses, punishments, or unmet needs from early development anchor the opposite story: “I can’t trust myself”.

This is why being told to “just believe in yourself” can feel so frustrating. It’s like being told to jump to the top of a ladder without being given the rungs to climb.

In reality, belief in sports is shaped by your nervous system, past experiences, and environment. Old mistakes can create insecure stories such as: “I’m not reliable in big moments.” And when doubt takes root, forcing belief under pressure feels impossible.

So when athletes ask: “How to believe in myself as an athlete?” the answer is not to try harder or think more positively. The answer is to rewire the patterns that keep you stuck in doubt and gradually build self-belief like a trainable skill.

Step 1: Start With Evidence, Not Imagination

Confidence is not something you can talk yourself into with a few pep talks, it’s something you build through evidence. If you’ve ever tried to hype yourself up before a game with “I’ve got this!” only to feel that voice crumble the moment nerves hit, you know imagination alone is not enough. One of the most effective ways to learn “how to believe in myself as an athlete” is to collect real proof that you are capable and resilient.

This is where micro-evidence comes in. Instead of aiming for the big, sweeping statement: “I am completely confident in every situation”, you can start stacking smaller, undeniable wins. Over time, these moments become deposits in your brain’s “confidence bank”. The more “deposits” you make, the easier it is to withdraw belief when you need it most.

Think about the moments that prove you’re growing as an athlete:

• “I finished my workout even when I was exhausted.”

• “I nailed my penalty saving routine every single time today.”

• “I bounced back quickly after receiving an easy goal instead of spiraling.”

• “I kept my focus during drills even when my mind started to wander.”

Each of these examples might feel small in the moment, but stacked together, they start to outweigh the old belief of “I can’t deliver a good performance”. This is how athletes transform doubt into trust, not with empty affirmations, but with patterns of consistent evidence.

Athlete Tip: It’s a really great idea to keep a performance journal. After each practice or competition, write down 2 – 3 specific examples where you showed resilience, discipline, or growth. Over time, this journal becomes a living record of your capability and strength – something you can return to when doubt tries to convince you otherwise.

Step 2: Train the Nervous System, Not Just the Mind

Most athletes assume confidence lives only in the mind – that if you think the right thoughts, belief will follow. But here’s the truth: if your body is stuck in fight-or-flight mode, no amount of positive thinking will survive. When your nervous system is flooded with stress, belief doesn’t feel real. It feels forced.

Think about those moments before competition when your heart races, your stomach knots, or your muscles feel heavy. That’s not “lack of motivation” – that’s your nervous system signaling danger. In those states, it’s almost impossible to trust yourself, no matter how badly you want to. This is why learning about “how to believe in myself as an athlete” has to start with calming the body, not just coaching the mind.

The good news? You can train your nervous system just like you train your sport. Simple tools help bring your body back into balance so confidence has a foundation to land on. Here are a few tips for how to do it:

• Breathing drills – Try box breathing (inhale 4, hold 4, exhale 4, hold 4) or “4-7-8 breathing”. These techniques lower stress hormones and steady your rhythm.

• Grounding techniques – Feel your feet press firmly into the ground, notice your breath in your chest, or focus on the textures of an object in your hand. This anchors your attention in the present moment.

• Orientation scans – Slowly move your eyes around the environment, noticing shapes, colors, and objects. This reminds your brain that you’re safe here and now.

By practicing these methods before training or competition, you send your body the message: “I can handle this, I am safe.” And when the body feels safe, the mind can finally start to believe.

Athlete Reminder: Confidence is not about shutting down nerves – it’s about regulating them. When you learn to manage your nervous system, you don’t just perform better, you create the conditions where belief can grow and stick.

Step 3: Use Behavior to Lead Belief

One of the biggest myths in sports is that “you have to feel confident first before you can perform well”. The reality is often the opposite: confidence grows from action. Sometimes, belief doesn’t show up until after you’ve already taken the step.

Think about a time when you didn’t feel ready, but you went for it anyway – took the shot, or made the save. Maybe your heart was pounding, your head was full of doubt, but once you took action, you realized: “I actually can do this.” That’s the principle at work here. Learning “how to believe in myself as an athlete” often means acting as if belief is already there, even when it isn’t.

Here’s a simple way to apply it: ask yourself: “If I already trusted myself fully in this moment, what would I do?”

Then commit to that behavior, whether it’s:

• Taking the penalty shot without hesitation.

• Speaking up with confidence in the locker room.

• Holding strong posture after a mistake instead of slumping.

Each time you do this, you send a powerful message to your brain: “My actions prove that I am capable.” Over time, those actions reshape your identity. This is what psychology calls “behavioral activation” – when action leads and belief follows.

Athlete Insight: Don’t wait for confidence to magically appear before you perform. Treat your behavior as the leader, and let your belief catch up. The more you practice this, the more natural confidence becomes, until belief is no longer something you chase, but it’s something you live.

Step 4: Reframe Your Inner Story

The words you tell yourself before, during, and after competition matter more than most athletes realize. The phrase “I can’t believe in myself” often feels like a fact, but it’s not. It’s a belief, and beliefs can be reshaped. If you carry that story long enough, it becomes part of your athletic identity, reinforcing the cycle of doubt and hesitation.

The good news is that you can start to rewrite that story. Just like adjusting your technique in training, you can adjust the language you use with yourself. Instead of demanding instant, unshakable belief, shift toward softer, growth-oriented statements. These take the pressure off perfection and open the door to slow, gradual progress.

For example:

• “I’m learning how to build confidence as an athlete.”

• “Some days I doubt myself, some days I believe in myself, and both are part of the process.”

• “Confidence is a skill, not a gift.”

When you make these small adjustments, you stop treating confidence as an all-or-nothing test which you will either pass or fail. You start treating it as a skill you practice, like footwork, ball handling, or endurance. Over time, this change in narrative creates more space for resilience and reduces the emotional weight of every mistake or setback.

Athlete Reminder: The story you repeat to yourself is like background music during a game – it shapes your rhythm, your pace, and your energy. Be careful and intentional, and choose words that support Growth rather than words that trap you in doubt.

Step 5: Borrow Confidence Until It’s Your Own

One of the biggest misconceptions in sports is that athletes are supposed to create confidence from “thin air” – that you either “have it” or you don’t. The truth is, belief doesn’t always start inside. Sometimes you need to “borrow it” until it grows strong enough to carry on its own. And there’s nothing bad or weak about that – it’s how most athletes build lasting confidence.

Think of it this way: you don’t always trust yourself in every moment, but you can trust the things around you. You can lean on the preparation you’ve already done – the countless drills, the conditioning, the hours of repetition. You can borrow steadiness and strength from a pre-competition routine that settles your nerves and reminds your body: “I’ve been here before.”

You can also borrow confidence from other people. A coach who believes in you, a teammate who speaks encouragement in the locker room, or even a mentor whose words you carry into competition can act as a bridge until you internalize that belief. Their trust in you doesn’t replace your own, but it plants seeds of possibility until those seeds grow roots.

Some of the feedback that has touched me most deeply as a coach (and as a human) came from young athletes who told me something along the lines of: ‘Thank you for believing in me so much that, in the end, I started to believe in myself.”  To me, that’s the actual power of borrowed confidence – it can grow into your own over time, especially if coaches are capable to reflect it strongly and clearly enough to their athletes.

Examples of “borrowing confidence” include:

• Trusting preparation: Remind yourself, “I’ve already put in the work, this moment is just an expression of it.”

• Leaning on mentors or teammates: Let their faith in you reflect back until you can see it too.

• Following rituals: Whether it’s a breathing pattern, a warm-up playlist, wearing the same pair of socks for every game, or lacing your shoes the same way, rituals provide stability when the mind wanders away

Think of these as “training wheels” for self-belief. They don’t hold you back – they keep you strong and on the right path until you’re ready to ride on your own. Over time, those borrowed pieces of confidence become yours, they start integrating into your identity as an athlete who can trust themselves in the most challenging moments.

Athlete Reminder: Borrowing confidence is not weakness – it’s strategy. Every champion or successful athlete, at some point, leaned on others, on systems, or on routines until their inner belief grew bigger.

Step 6: Anchor Into Core Values

When athletes struggle with doubt, the question often becomes: “How to believe in myself as an athlete when I don’t feel confident?” One powerful way forward is to zoom out and connect to something bigger than the immediate pressure of performance. Belief is much easier to access when it’s grounded in your deeper values – not just in results.

Performance is unpredictable. Some days you will win, some days you will lose. But your values – what you stand for – can stay steady no matter the result or stress during the match. When you show up anchored in your values, your identity is not shaken every time you get an easy goal during a game. Instead, you compete from a place of alignment: “This is who I am, and this is what I stand for.”

Ask yourself questions like:

• “Why do I compete beyond winning or proving myself?”

• “What values guide me when the outcome is out of my control?”

• “Who do I want to be remembered as when I walk off the court”

For some athletes, the answer might be perseverance – never quitting no matter the score. For others, it could be integrity – competing with fairness and respect. For many, it’s courage – choosing to step into the hardest moments of the competition even when fear or doubt are loud.

When you act from your values, you bypass the fragile question of confidence. You stop asking, “Do I believe in myself right now?” and instead, you remind yourself: “I’m showing up because this is what I stand for.” That shift takes the pressure off perfection and creates a stronger foundation for belief to grow.

Athlete Reminder: Wins and losses fade, but the way you live your values leaves a lasting mark – on you, on your team, and on the people watching. Compete for who you are, not just for what you achieve.

Step 7: Rewrite Past Experiences

Every athlete carries memories of tough moments – missing the game-winning shot, losing a championship, being criticized by a coach, or making a big mistake when it mattered most. These moments can stick like scars, replaying in your mind whenever you face pressure again. Over time, they can solidify in your mind into a belief: “I can’t trust myself when it counts.”

But here’s the truth: the past doesn’t have to keep defining you. Those memories don’t have to be proof that you will always fall short – they can become lessons that build resilience. Learning how to believe in myself as an athlete means being willing to revisit those experiences, not to relive the pain, but to rewrite the story they left behind.

Here are a few ways to start that process:

• Write about the event from your present perspective. With the wisdom and experience you have now, what do you see that your younger or previous self couldn’t?

• Speak to your younger self. Ask: “What would I say to myself in that moment if I could go back? What support, kindness, or truth would I want to hear?”

• Reframe the memory. Instead of labeling it as a permanent failure, try seeing it as a stepping stone – an experience that strengthened your mindset, sharpened your focus, or prepared you for the next challenge.

This shift doesn’t erase what happened, but it frees you from being trapped by it. When you rewrite past experiences with compassion, you loosen the grip of old identities and create space for new confidence to grow.

Athlete Reminder: Failure doesn’t mean “I’m not good enough.” It often means: “I was being stretched to a new level.” When you reframe your story, your past becomes fuel for your future instead of a weight holding you back.

Step 8: Train Self-Compassion Alongside Toughness

In sports, athletes are often taught to “be tough,” to push through pain, to silence emotions, and to hold themselves to the highest possible standard. And while toughness can fuel performance, toughness without compassion is unstable – it often collapses the moment things don’t go perfectly. True resilience comes from combining discipline with kindness.

Self-compassion doesn’t mean lowering your standards or letting yourself off the hook. It means staying supportive toward yourself in the very moments where your inner critic wants to break you down. Think of it this way: toughness sets the bar, that’s true, but compassion gives you the strength to keep reaching for it without breaking down.

You can start practicing this by noticing your self-talk in high pressure situations:

• When the voice in your head says: “I always choke,” try changing and reframing it to: “I’m learning how to handle pressure.”

• Instead of saying: “I messed up again”, try: “Mistakes are part of the process, I can reset and move forward.”

A simple rule that can help you: speak to yourself the way you would to a teammate. If a teammate missed a shot, you probably wouldn’t yell at them: “You’re worthless!”, you would say: “It’s ok, shake it off, you’ll get the next one!” That same level of support is what your own performance deserves.

And here’s an important reminder: doubt is not proof of weakness. It’s proof that you’re human. Even the best athletes in the world doubt themselves sometimes. The difference is, they don’t let doubt turn into self-destruction. They meet it with perspective and self-support (by using helpful tools and strategies), and then they get back to work.

Athlete Reminder: Toughness alone can push you for a moment, but toughness combined with self-compassion keeps you consistent for a whole career.

Step 9: Build Belief Like a Muscle

Many athletes think confidence should show up instantly – like flipping a switch before competition. But real self-belief doesn’t come from a single pep talk or a motivational quote. It’s built gradually, the same way you build physical strength: through repetition, training, and consistency over time.

Think of confidence as a muscle. Every time you complete a small daily habit – whether it’s writing down proof of your own progress, practicing a breathing drill, or sticking to your pre-performance routine – you’re adding one more “repetition” to that muscle. On its own, it may not feel “transformative” or big. But stacked together over time, those repetitions grow into strength that carries you through high pressure moments.

Setbacks are part of this process, too. Just like sore muscles after a hard workout, moments of doubt or failure don’t mean that you are weak – they mean that you are adapting and Growing. Each obstacle becomes part of the training that makes your belief more resilient.

Most importantly, it’s not about intensity, it’s about consistency. One intense pep talk won’t change your confidence forever, just like one heavy workout won’t make you strong. But steady, repeated practice – day after day, week after week – gradually shifts your identity from “I’m not sure that I can do it” to: “This is simply who I am as an athlete. Sometimes I fall, but I will always get up and keep working.”

Athlete Reminder: Keep showing up for your confidence the same way you show up for your training. Over time, you will stop asking “how to believe in myself as an athlete”, because self-belief will no longer be something that you are trying to “chase”. It will be something that you live all the time.

Conclusion: From Doubt to Strength

Belief in sports isn’t “magic” – it’s method. It’s not about waiting for the perfect day when confidence suddenly shows up, and it’s not about forcing yourself to “just believe”. Self-belief is something that you build, step by step, through habits, experiences, and the way you respond to challenges.

If you feel unable to believe in yourself as an athlete, remember that you are not broken – you are just human. Every athlete wrestles with doubt at some point, whether they admit it or not. The difference between those who stay stuck in doubt, and those who rise is learning how to train belief the same way they train their sport.

Here’s the path forward:

• Collect micro-evidence – Gather small wins until your brain sees the proof.

• Train your nervous system – Calm your body so belief can stick.

• Act as if belief is already there – Let behavior lead the way.

• Reframe your story – Shift “I can’t” into “I’m learning.”

• Borrow external support – Lean on routines, mentors, and teammates until belief takes root.

• Anchor into values – Compete for who you are, not just for what you achieve.

• Rewrite old failures – Turn past scars into stepping stones.

• Practice self-compassion – Stay supportive to yourself when doubt shows up.

• Build belief like a muscle – Train it with consistency, not just intensity.

When you combine these steps, belief stops being a fragile, insecure feeling – and it becomes part of your foundation as an athlete. You start showing up with steadiness and inner strength, even when the moment is big and the pressure is high.

Your Challenge: This week, choose at least one strategy from the list above and commit to trying it out and practicing it. Maybe it’s writing down micro-evidence after training, or trying out a breathing exercise before competition, or catching and reframing your self-talk. Then reflect: “What changed for me when I gave myself permission to train belief, not just expect it?”

And if you realize that you would benefit from help and deeper guidance in this work (whether you’re a handball goalkeeper, an athlete in any sport, or a coach) I offer 1:1 coaching support to help you build confidence, strengthen belief, and unlock your best performance. You don’t have to climb this “mountain” alone. Feel free to reach out and contact me, and we can explore ways to take the next step together.

Remember: belief is not something you wait for to “show up” – it’s something that you build. Step by step, repetition by repetition, you can turn doubt into strength and performance into possibility.

Stay in Touch

You can let me know what topics you have the biggest challenge with in goalkeeper coaching by filling out this form.

If you would like to get updates about my online and in-person projects, my research papers, my creative projects (such as blog posts, books and e-books), about my ongoing and new online programs, please subscribe to my newsletter and then you won’t miss any updates and news.

Here you can find my online video courses: Level 1 Video Course for Coaches; Level 2 Video Course for Coaches; Sliding Technique Video Course and Agility Ladder Drills Video Collection with 102 drills.

Subject to Copyright

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of any part of content from this website without express and written permission from this site’s owner is strictly prohibited.  All content (such as text, data, graphics files, images, illustrations, videos, sound files), and all other materials contained in www.vanjaradic.fi are copyrighted unless otherwise noted and are the property of Vanja Radic Coaching. If you want to cite or use any part of the content from my website, you need to get the permission first, so please contact me for that matter.