What If I Fail? Understanding the Fear of Failure in Athletes

In the time before any big moment, before a match, a tryout, or a single penalty shot, a small question tends to surface in an athlete’s mind: “What if I fail?” It comes uninvited, it tightens the chest and body, and it can almost destroy what an athlete is willing to attempt. The fear of failure in athletes is one of the most common experiences in all of sport, familiar to beginners and Olympians alike, and understanding it is one of the most useful things we can do for the people we coach. That question, “What if I fail?”, deserves a closer look, because the way an athlete keeps it in their mind shapes how they compete, how they recover, and sometimes whether they keep going at all.

I want to talk about what this fear actually is, why it shows up in so many athletes, where it tends to come from, and how an athlete can choose a more calm (and more productive) question and replace it whenever “What if I fail?” shows up. Along the way, I’ll lean on the research in this article, and I’ll keep one idea in view from the start: failure itself and the fear of failure are two very different things, and the actual work is in changing an athlete’s relationship with both those ideas.

Key Takeaways

• Athletes fear the consequences of failing more than the failure itself. Research identifies five common fears behind the question, including shame, a damaged self-image, and disappointing the people who matter, so naming the specific fear gives an athlete something concrete to work on.
• The fear leaves clear fingerprints on performance. Playing not to lose, self-handicapping, and avoidance are all signs of fear of failure at work, and over time the fear is linked with anxiety, perfectionism, burnout, and dropout.
• Fear of failure is learned, often early. Punitive responses, controlling behavior, and high-pressure expectations from parents and coaches can plant it, while mastery-focused and autonomy-supportive environments are linked with less of it.
• Failure earns its place as a teacher. Getting things wrong is how athletes gather the information that builds skill, and every successful athlete has a long history of failures behind them, which takes the threat out of failing.
• A forward question lowers the fear. Letting “What if I fail?” grow into “What will I do after I fail?” moves an athlete’s attention onto a response they can control, which shrinks the threat and frees them to compete with courage.

The Question Almost Every Athlete Asks

If you’ve coached for any length of time, you’ve watched this fear move through your athletes, even the talented and well-prepared ones. It shows up as the player who holds back in the tryout, the goalkeeper who stops committing to saves after one easy goal, the runner who talks themselves out of the race days before it starts. The fear of failure in athletes rarely announces itself. It hides inside hesitation, inside a sudden drop in effort, inside the athlete who suddenly “doesn’t care” about something they clearly care about deeply.

What makes the question “What if I fail?” so powerful is that it feels protective. The mind believes that by rehearsing the worst outcome and the worst possible scenario, it can somehow prevent it, or at least prepare for it. The challenge is that this rehearsal pulls an athlete out of the present moment, where performance actually happens, and puts them into an imagined future where they’ve already lost. An athlete stuck in that loop competes against their own anxiety as much as against their opponent. Naming this fear as a near-universal experience is the first step, because an athlete who believes they’re the only one feeling it tends to keep shame on top of the fear itself.

What the Fear of Failure Actually Is

Sport psychology gives us a clearer picture of this fear, and the picture is more specific than most people expect. The researcher David Conroy and his colleagues built one of the most widely used measures in this area, and their work revealed something important: athletes high in fear of failure don’t actually fear failure itself so much as the unpleasant consequences they expect failure to bring. The fear attaches to what failing seems to mean and what it seems to cost. Put simply, what frightens athletes most is everything that failing might bring with it: the embarrassment, the letdown they picture on a coach’s or parent’s face, the worry about what one bad result means for their future.

Conroy’s model describes five consequences that athletes commonly fear when they imagine failing. There’s the fear of experiencing shame and embarrassment. There’s the fear of devaluing one’s own self-estimate, the sense that failing proves you’re less capable than you hoped. There’s the fear of an uncertain future, the worry that this failure derails your plans. There’s the fear that important people will lose interest in you. And there’s the fear of upsetting the people whose opinion you appreciate the most, like a parent or a coach. When an athlete asks “What if I fail?”, one or more of these five fears is usually doing the talking underneath.

This matters for how we can help, because it gives us somewhere specific to look. The same research found that fear of failure tends to go together with worry, physical anxiety symptoms, disrupted concentration, and lower optimism. An athlete who can identify which of those five consequences they actually fear gains a real advantage, because a vague dread is much harder to work with than a named one. Helping an athlete move from: “I’m scared of failing” to: “I’m scared my coach will think less of me” turns an unclear “fog” into something they can address directly.

How Fear of Failure Shows Up in Performance

The fear of failure in athletes leaves fingerprints all over performance, and learning to read them helps us catch it early. One of the most common signs is an athlete shifting from playing to win toward playing not to lose. Those two states look similar from the outside, but they produce very different outcome and performance. An athlete protecting themselves against failure plays small, avoids risks, and holds back the very boldness that their best performances require.

Self-handicapping is another pattern worth watching for. An athlete might stop trying fully, skip preparation, or invent an excuse in advance, all so that any failure can be blamed on the lack of effort rather than on a lack of ability. It feels safer to fail while “not really trying” than to give everything and still fail in the end. There’s also the avoidance that keeps athletes from opportunities altogether, the trial they skip and the selection they choose to opt out of, which protects them from failure at the cost of their growth.

There’s a physical signature too, one that coaches learn to spot. Fear of failure in athletes often shows up as a body that tightens at the decisive moment, as muscles that lose their softness in the movement, or breathing that turns shallow and fast. An athlete in the grip of this fear tends to overthink simple actions they’d normally perform on instinct, second-guessing a pass or a shot they’ve made a thousand times. The mind, busy protecting against the imagined disaster, steals the very resources the athlete needs to perform, which is one of the cruel ironies of this fear: bracing against failure often makes failure more likely to happen.

Over time, this fear carries a heavier toll. Research on young handball players has connected fear of failure with higher burnout and the stress that wears athletes down, and the broader literature links it with anxiety, perfectionism, and dropping out of sport altogether. An athlete who spends years protecting against failure pays for it in enjoyment and longevity, which is part of why this topic deserves a serious attention rather than just a short pep talk.

Where the Fear Comes From

Fear of failure is learned, and understanding how it develops helps us approach it with compassion rather than judgment. Much of it takes root early, in the environment around a young athlete, through the messages they get about what failing actually means.

Research by Sam Sagar and David Lavallee into the developmental origins of fear of failure in young athletes found that certain patterns in how parents engage with sport can feed the fear. They pointed to three in particular: punitive responses to failure, controlling behavior, and consistently high expectations for achievement. When a child learns that a poor performance brings punishment, withdrawn warmth, or visible disappointment from the people they love most, failure starts to feel genuinely dangerous, and the fear settles in for the long time.

Coaches shape this too, sometimes even more than parents do. Perceived pressure and criticism from coaches has been tied to perfectionism and to fear of failure, and the way a coach responds to mistakes teaches athletes what failure is going to cost them in this environment. None of this is about blaming parents or coaches, who almost always act out of love and a wish to see their athlete do well. It’s about seeing the mechanism clearly, because when we understand that fear of failure grows in certain conditions, we can change those conditions.

The fear doesn’t come only from the outside, either. As athletes grow, many internalize these early lessons and become their own harshest critics, holding themselves to standards no coach ever set. An athlete whose sense of who they are has become tightly bound to their results has the most to lose from failing, because a bad performance threatens their very identity along with their score. This is why two athletes in the same environment can have such different levels of fear: each one is also responding to their own history and the story in their minds they’ve built about what failing says about them.

The encouraging opposite side of the same research is that mastery-focused and autonomy-supportive environments, the ones that treat mistakes as part of learning, are connected with lower fear of failure. The climate we build inside of our teams genuinely makes the difference.

Failure Deserves a Better Reputation

Here is where your own instinct about this topic remains valid. Failure works as one of the most reliable teachers an athlete will ever have. In the process of learning any difficult skill, getting things wrong is how the brain gathers the information it needs to get things right. A goalkeeper learns the timing of a save by mistiming it many times first. A shooter finds their range by missing high and low until their body calibrates. The mistakes are the necessary curriculum, and an athlete who could somehow avoid all failure would also avoid all of the learning that comes with it.

The athletes and performers I admire most reached their level by failing more often than most people even attempt. Every athlete who has lifted a trophy has a long history of losses behind them, and the willingness to keep failing until they succeeded is a large part of what separated them. I’ve written more about this in my piece on learning from failure in sport, where the shift from fearing mistakes toward using them changes everything about how an athlete grows. When we help athletes see failure as the price of admission for anything worth doing, the question “What if I fail?” starts to lose some of its power, because the answer becomes “Then I’ll be exactly where every successful athlete has stood.”

It helps to share concrete proof of this with athletes. The history of every sport is full of champions who were cut from teams, who lost final after final before they won one, who missed a decisive shot and came back to take it again. Those stories are the standard route to the top, repeated in nearly every sport. When an athlete understands that the people at the very summit failed their way there, the fear of failure in athletes starts to look less like a warning and more like a sign that they’re attempting something worth the risk.

This reframing takes the pressure off in a practical way. An athlete who accepts failure as part of the path stops treating each attempt as a referendum on their worth, which frees them to take the risks that growth and great performances demand.

From “What If I Fail?” to a Calmer Question

The fear behind “What if I fail?” comes largely from how the question points an athlete’s mind: toward an uncontrollable outcome, set in the future, loaded with imagined consequences. We can teach athletes to let that question grow into a second one that points somewhere far more useful. After “What if I fail?” comes a calmer follow-up: “What will I do after I fail?”

That forward-looking question changes what the body does with the fear, because it moves an athlete’s attention onto something they can actually control: their response. Failure stops being a cliff edge and becomes a moment they already have a plan for. An athlete who knows they’ll respond to a mistake with a reset breath and the next action has taken much of the threat out of failing before they ever step onto the court. The fear shrinks because the unknown shrinks. This connects closely to the idea of focusing on controllable actions, which I explore in my work on building genuine self-belief, since self-belief in athletes grows from evidence and preparation rather than from forced positivity.

Self-compassion belongs in this conversation as well. An athlete who meets their own failures with the same kindness they’d offer a struggling teammate recovers faster and stays in the game longer. Harsh self-criticism after a failure keeps the nervous system activated and makes the fear of the next attempt even sharper. Teaching athletes to talk to themselves like someone they’re rooting for, especially right after a mistake, builds the resilience that lets them keep showing up. The athlete who can fail and still treat themselves well has found something close to freedom in their sport.

How Coaches and Parents Can Help

The adults around an athlete hold real power to lower this fear, and a few deliberate choices make a large difference. The aim is to build an environment where failure is safe enough that athletes will keep daring to try.

The most important shift is separating an athlete’s performance from their worth. When a child knows that your warmth and belief in them stay constant whether they win or lose, failure stops threatening the thing they need most, which is your steady regard. Coaching that supports autonomy rather than controlling and pressuring athletes is connected with lower fear of failure, so giving athletes voice, choice, and reasoning behind your decisions pays off directly here. Responding to mistakes with curiosity, with a simple question: “What did we learn there?” rather than visible frustration, teaches athletes that failure is information instead of disaster.

Modeling matters a lot, too. When a coach or parent can speak openly about their own failures and what they did next, they show the young athlete that failing is survivable and normal, even for the people they look up to. The language you use settles into an athlete’s own inner voice over time, so changing: “Don’t mess up” with: “Go after it” or: “Focus on your first move” points them toward action rather than fear. Small changes in how the adults respond to failure reshape what failure means to the athlete, and that meaning is the root of the whole thing.

What Athletes Can Do for Themselves

Athletes have real power here too, and the work starts with a few accessible practices. The first is simply naming the fear out loud, since a fear spoken tends to lose some of its grip compared to one that runs silently in the background. Using Conroy’s five consequences as a lens, an athlete can ask themselves which one they actually fear most, which turns a vague dread into a specific worry they can work on.

From there, the forward question becomes a daily habit. Before an attempt, an athlete can decide in advance how they’ll respond if it goes badly, which builds a sense of readiness that crowds out some of the fear. Focusing on the controllable actions in front of them keeps their mind in the present rather than in an imagined future, and pairing that focus with self-kindness after any mistake helps them recover and re-engage. None of these practices erase fear completely, and they’re not meant to. They give an athlete a way to act bravely while the fear is present, which is what courage has always actually meant.

It also helps athletes to widen their definition of a good performance. When success gets measured only by the result, every outcome outside an athlete’s control becomes a potential failure, and the fear grows to match. An athlete who also counts the quality of their effort, their composure under pressure, and the courage it took to try at all gives themselves more ways to walk away proud. That wider scorecard keeps their standards intact while handing them a more fair picture of what they actually did, which calms down their confidence across the ups and downs of a long season.

A Challenge to Keep Into Your Next Attempt

Here is the one thing I’d ask you to try, whether you coach or compete. I have been using this always in my coaching, and also in my life overall, and it’s really efficient. The next time you notice the question: “What if I fail?” rising up in your mind and body before something that matters, let it be there, and then add the second question right behind it: “What will I do after I fail?” Answer that second question concretely, with the actual next step you’d take, and notice how the fear changes shape once you’ve given it a plan to hit against. 😁☺️

The fear of failure in athletes will never disappear entirely, and it doesn’t need to. It shows up because the athlete cares, and that caring is the same fuel that powers everything good in their sport. The work is in changing the athlete’s relationship with failing, so that the question that once shrank them starts to point them forward instead. Failure is close to a guarantee on the road to anything worth achieving, and an athlete who has made peace with that truth carries a freedom that fear can no longer touch.☺️

Stay in Touch
Do you have any coaching challenges you’d like me to address? Let me know what topics you struggle with most in goalkeeper coaching by filling out this form.

Never miss an update
Subscribe to my newsletter to receive updates about my online and in-person projects, research papers, creative projects (blog posts, books, e-books), and new online programs.

My Online Video Courses:
– Level 1 Video Course for Coaches
– Level 2 Video Course for Coaches
– Sliding Technique Video Course
– Agility Ladder Drills Video Collection – 102 drills

Subject to Copyright
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of any content from this website without express written permission from this site’s owner is strictly prohibited. All content (including text, data, graphics files, images, illustrations, videos, and sound files) contained in www.vanjaradic.fi is copyrighted unless otherwise noted and is the property of Vanja Radic Coaching. If you wish to cite or use any content from my website, please contact me first to obtain permission.